Trevor Stinson

talk to me on twitter / subscribe via email or rss

Open and Shut | Daring Fireball

Even more telling, and more damning to Wu’s use of this as a case study, is that soon after Windows 95, Apple radically opened up the Mac OS, in a use of the word “open” that Wu expressly states is what he means by the term: they licensed the OS to other PC makers to produce Mac clones. This was the most open decision — in Wu’s sense of the word open — in the entire history of Apple Computer Inc.

And it nearly bankrupted the company.

This whole article is a solid refutation of the “open beats closed” axiom. “Open” is important for standards and the Internet, but in most cases it’s simply a matter of “better beats worse.”